I still remember the 2019 Honda PBA Philippine Cup season like it was yesterday, and looking back at those standings gives me such a vivid picture of how dramatically things can shift in professional basketball. The San Miguel Beermen ultimately claimed the championship that year, but what struck me most was how their journey reflected the kind of strategic roster decisions we're now seeing in volleyball, particularly with Steven Rotter's surprising exclusion from the Alas Pilipinas Men's 14-man squad for the 2025 FIVB Volleyball Men's World Championship. Both scenarios highlight how team management often makes controversial choices that leave fans and analysts scratching their heads, yet sometimes these very decisions lead to unexpected successes.
The 2019 Philippine Cup standings showed San Miguel finishing the elimination round with 9 wins against 2 losses, placing them second behind the Phoenix Fuel Masters who had an impressive 10-1 record. What many people don't remember is that San Miguel actually struggled early in the season, losing two of their first five games before going on that incredible 7-game winning streak. I've always believed that their mid-season turnaround came down to June Mar Fajardo finding his rhythm after dealing with minor injuries early on. The Beermen's path to the championship wasn't straightforward - they needed six games to get past TNT in the semifinals before facing Magnolia in a finals series that went the full seven games. That final game was absolutely electrifying, with San Miguel pulling away in the fourth quarter to win 72-71 in what remains one of the closest finishes in recent PBA memory.
What fascinates me about analyzing these standings is how they reveal patterns that transcend different sports. When I look at Steven Rotter being left out of the volleyball national team, it reminds me of how certain PBA teams made roster decisions that seemed questionable at the time but ultimately worked in their favor. Take Rain or Shine's decision to trade James Yap before the 2019 season - many critics called it a mistake, but it allowed them to develop younger players who contributed to their 7-4 record and quarterfinals appearance. Similarly, I suspect the volleyball selectors might have specific tactical reasons for Rotter's omission that we're not privy to, just as PBA coaches often have behind-the-scenes insights that inform their roster moves.
The middle part of that 2019 standings table was incredibly tight, with four teams finishing with identical 6-5 records. Alaska, Barangay Ginebra, Magnolia, and NorthPort all had to fight through tie-breakers to determine playoff positioning, and I've always felt this congestion reflected the league's competitive balance at its best. Magnolia's journey from that logjam to the finals was particularly impressive, proving that regular season standings don't always predict playoff success. Their coach Chito Victolero made some brilliant adjustments throughout the playoffs, much like how national team coaches across different sports must make difficult selection choices based on current form and tactical fit rather than past reputation.
Looking at the bottom of those 2019 standings, Blackwater finished with the worst record at 1-10, while Columbian and NLEX weren't much better at 3-8 each. These struggling teams remind me that rebuilding processes take time, and sometimes excluding established players - whether in basketball or volleyball - is part of a longer-term development strategy. I can't help but wonder if the Alas Pilipinas selectors are thinking similarly about Rotter, perhaps looking to build chemistry among younger players who might develop better without a veteran presence dominating playing time.
The parallel between these two situations across different sports and years highlights how team management in Philippine sports often follows similar patterns. Having followed both basketball and volleyball closely for over a decade, I've noticed that our national teams and professional leagues tend to prioritize specific playing styles over individual talent, which sometimes leads to these surprising exclusions. In the 2019 PBA season, we saw several notable players traded or receiving limited minutes because they didn't fit their team's system, much like Rotter's current situation.
Reflecting on that 2019 PBA season and comparing it to today's volleyball selection dilemmas gives me a deeper appreciation for how complex team management decisions can be. The standings tell only part of the story - what happens behind closed doors, the practice sessions we don't see, the chemistry issues coaches must navigate - these are the real factors that determine both roster choices and ultimate success. While I personally would have liked to see Rotter included given his international experience, I understand that selectors have access to information and insights that we fans don't. Just as San Miguel's championship validated their regular season decisions, perhaps the Alas Pilipinas team's performance will eventually justify what currently seems like a puzzling omission.